What two very different managers taught me about leadership, trust and the environments in which people thrive.
I've worked across a few very different industries throughout my career.
None of which I would have imagined working in when I was at university studying primary education!
Like many people, my career has taken some unexpected turns, usually for the better. Along the way, I've had the privilege of working with some exceptional leaders.
But I've also noticed a recurring pattern.
I'll join an organisation because I genuinely connect with the leader I'm going to work for. Things go well, the relationship develops, and then, for one reason or another, the leadership changes.
Suddenly, the person I'm reporting to is almost the complete opposite of the person who hired me.
Perhaps you've experienced something similar.
Now, I'm a big believer that not every leader we work with will be perfect.
Heck, I'm certainly not!
I'm sure there are people I've managed over the years who wouldn't put me at the top of their list of favourite bosses. I can probably name a few of them myself.
But I've also been fortunate enough to work with leaders who knew how to bring out the best in me while still holding me accountable.
They challenged me. They trusted me. They gave me room to grow.
And when I think back over my career, those are the leaders I remember as the wise mentors along my own rather unconventional hero's journey.
I want to tell you about two managers I worked for in the same organisation.
Same role. Same person doing the job.
Two completely different working environments.
For the privacy of those involved, I've changed the names, organisation, industry and certain identifying details.
But the leadership lessons are very real.
The Manager Who Brought Out My Best
Years ago, I joined an organisation we'll call Dreamtec to lead its contact centre.
The team was responsible for receiving customer orders and coordinating their fulfilment.
My manager was a woman I'll call Bonita.
And she was amazing.
Bonita knew her business. She knew her people. And she understood how to create an environment where performance, growth, innovation and accountability could flourish.
She approached situations with a genuine desire to understand before being understood.
Importantly, she respected the expertise of the people she'd employed.
She treated me as an experienced contact centre leader, a coach and a senior manager who had something valuable to contribute.
That didn't mean I could do whatever I wanted.
Quite the opposite.
Bonita had high expectations. She expected results, sound judgement, accountability and honest conversations.
But she also gave me the trust and freedom to deliver.
And I loved working for her.
In fact, if I'd had the opportunity to work for Bonita for the remainder of my corporate career, I would have been very happy to do so.
Best. Boss. Ever.
Trust Doesn't Mean Avoiding Difficult Decisions
The first six months were anything but easy.
I inherited an operation that needed significant work.
An underperforming team had to be closed. We needed to change how the wider business perceived the contact centre.
There were staffing decisions to make, people to recruit, technology to improve, IVR systems to address and longstanding ways of working that needed to change.
Some decisions were difficult.
Some were unpopular.
And not everything worked perfectly the first time.
But through those challenges, Bonita stood beside me.
She supported me in difficult conversations with the Executive General Manager (EGM). She trusted my operational judgement. When I needed guidance, she provided it. When I needed freedom to act, she gave it.
She didn't remove accountability.
She created the conditions in which I could accept it.
And the operation moved forward.
That experience reinforced something I'd already begun to recognise about good leadership.
People often achieve their best results when they're trusted to do their jobs, supported when things become difficult and held accountable for what they deliver.
Unfortunately, that environment was about to change.
Enter the New Manager
Around six months into my role, organisational restructuring was taking place.
Bonita was moved into another division, and I found myself reporting to a new manager.
We'll call him Roberto.
Roberto had taken a very different route into leadership.
He'd begun in an operational role within a related business, worked his way through various positions and eventually become responsible for its contact centre network.
There's nothing wrong with that pathway.
Some of the best leaders I've known have worked their way through an organisation, gaining invaluable practical experience along the way.
The problem wasn't where Roberto had come from.
It was how he chose to lead.
As part of the restructure, the contact centres of two related businesses were merged.
I now had more operational responsibility, fewer resources and a new manager.
At first, Roberto seemed pleasant enough.
But it quickly became apparent that his leadership style was very different from Bonita's.
Where Bonita empowered, Roberto controlled.
Where Bonita listened, Roberto directed.
Where Bonita valued the specialist expertise I'd brought into the business, Roberto frequently challenged it, sometimes on the basis of practices that might work in a four-person operation but simply wouldn't scale to a contact centre with more than a hundred employees.
We disagreed.
Quite often.
Now, disagreement itself isn't a problem. Leaders should be able to challenge one another's thinking.
Some of the best decisions I've been involved in have come from robust conversations where people saw things differently.
But there is an important difference between challenging someone's ideas and undermining the person presenting them.
And I was about to experience that difference firsthand.
The Day He Kicked My Chair
One of my responsibilities was chairing a daily multidisciplinary meeting.
I'd been running these meetings for approximately eight months.
Representatives from several parts of the business attended, and the purpose was straightforward: coordinate the operation so customers received their deliveries on time.
We reviewed available stock, discussed customer commitments and worked through which orders could be fulfilled, which might need to be delayed and where alternative arrangements were necessary.
It was an important operational meeting with real consequences for customers.
Although I chaired it, different participants contributed information and presented updates. My responsibility was to coordinate the discussion, agree on actions and ensure the wider team delivered on the outcomes.
On this particular day, Roberto was also in the room.
He was sitting slightly behind me and off to one side.
As another participant finished speaking, I was taking notes about the decisions we'd made.
Roberto began talking.
I was still finishing my notes when, about a sentence into his contribution, he kicked my chair.
Then he challenged me about whether I was listening.
I turned and acknowledged him politely.
But underneath?
I was absolutely fuming.
I was embarrassed by what had happened, particularly in front of colleagues whom I was responsible for leading.
And, frankly, I was embarrassed for him.
The room went silent.
For what felt like an eternity.
I asked Roberto to continue, and somehow we made it through the remainder of the meeting.
But I knew that what had happened wasn't acceptable.
Not from a colleague.
Not from a team member.
And certainly not from a senior leader.
What I Wanted to Do — and What I Actually Did
Walking back to my desk, I was angry.
Very angry.
But thankfully, I had enough presence of mind not to confront Roberto immediately.
That conversation would not have gone particularly well.
My emotions were running high, and I knew I needed to respond thoughtfully rather than react impulsively.
Then the Teams messages started arriving.
Several people who'd attended the meeting contacted me privately.
Was I okay?
What had happened?
How was I going to respond?
I thanked them for checking in and reassured them that I was okay.
What I didn't share was just how angry and disappointed I felt.
Because something else mattered here.
The people who'd witnessed the incident were also watching how I would respond.
I had a responsibility to model the behaviour I expected from my own team, even when someone more senior hadn't done the same.
So I reached out to Bonita.
Although she was no longer my manager, I trusted her judgement and valued her perspective.
I explained what had happened, how I was feeling and how I was considering responding.
She gave me the calm, objective perspective I needed.
Later that afternoon, I arranged a private meeting with Roberto.
I explained the incident from my perspective, told him how his behaviour had affected me and gave him the opportunity to respond.
I also made my expectations clear.
If the behaviour stopped, we could move forward and leave the matter there.
If anything similar happened again, I would consider formal escalation through HR.
I'd documented the incident contemporaneously so I had an accurate record if it became necessary.
I genuinely hoped that would be the end of it.
Unfortunately, it wasn't.
When Disagreement Became Something More
Over the following weeks, Roberto made several operational decisions I didn't agree with.
I tried to work within them where I reasonably could.
But eventually, another situation arose that made the breakdown in trust impossible to ignore.
We were attending a meeting with the EGM and a group of senior colleagues.
Roberto presented a proposed change to the contact centre's IVR system.
For anyone unfamiliar with the term, IVR refers to the automated phone menu and call-routing system customers encounter when they contact an organisation.
Roberto presented the change as an approach I supported.
In fact, he went further and attributed the idea to me.
There was just one problem.
It wasn't my idea. And I didn't support it.
When Roberto had originally raised the proposal with me, I'd explained my concerns and used the available operational data to demonstrate why I believed it would increase customer waiting times.
Nevertheless, here we were, with the proposal being presented to the EGM as though it had my endorsement.
The EGM questioned the approach.
I had a decision to make.
Stay quiet and allow the group to believe I'd recommended something I considered operationally unsound?
Or respectfully correct the record?
I chose the latter.
I explained that I hadn't proposed the change, that I didn't support it and why I believed it would create problems.
Then the EGM asked a perfectly reasonable question.
What would I recommend instead?
I outlined an alternative approach I'd developed and discussed with Roberto approximately three months earlier.
At the time, Roberto had told me he'd taken the proposal to the EGM and that it had been rejected.
But as I explained the idea in the meeting, something interesting happened.
The EGM said he'd never heard of it.
And, having listened to the proposal, he wanted to know why we hadn't implemented it already.
I explained that I'd previously been advised the idea hadn't received his support.
Roberto was now a very noticeable shade of red.
The EGM instructed me to proceed.
So I did.
And the results followed almost immediately.
Same Role. Same Capabilities. Different Environment.
It wasn't long after these events that I left the organisation.
The circumstances of my departure aren't the important part of this story.
What matters is the difference between those two leadership experiences.
Under Bonita, I had responsibility, accountability and considerable challenges.
Under Roberto, I still had responsibility, accountability and considerable challenges.
The job hadn't fundamentally changed.
Neither had my underlying capabilities.
But the environment had.
One manager created the conditions in which I felt trusted, respected and able to contribute at my best.
The other created an environment where I became increasingly cautious, frustrated and focused on getting through the day.
Under the first manager, I thrived. Under the second, I tried to make it work, then found myself increasingly in survival mode.
And eventually, I left.
That contrast taught me something I've carried into every leadership role since.
Leaders Create the Conditions
I've come to believe that leaders have an enormous influence over whether their people survive, strive or thrive.
And, sadly, whether they eventually lose the enthusiasm and confidence they once brought to the job.
Think about what Bonita actually did.
She didn't magically remove operational problems.
She didn't lower expectations.
She didn't protect me from every difficult conversation.
She trusted me, challenged me, supported me and held me accountable.
The result was an environment where I wanted to contribute more.
Now think about what changed under Roberto.
The work was still important.
The operational challenges were still real.
But trust, professional respect and psychological safety had deteriorated.
The energy I once directed towards improving the operation was increasingly being consumed by navigating the relationship.
And that's a terrible waste of capability.
A leader doesn't have to be perfect to create a great working environment. But they do need to understand how their behaviour affects the people around them.
I certainly haven't always got that right myself.
There have been times when I've been too impatient, too direct or too convinced that my own approach was the right one.
And I've needed people to challenge me about that.
But those experiences have made me increasingly conscious of something important.
Leadership isn't simply about getting results through people.
It's also about creating the conditions in which people can deliver those results without losing themselves in the process.
What Does This Mean for Your Career?
There's another side to this story.
If you're considering a promotion, a new employer or a change in career direction, don't focus solely on the job description, salary and title.
Ask questions about the environment.
What is the manager's leadership style?
How are decisions made?
What happens when someone disagrees?
How much autonomy does the role genuinely have?
How does the organisation respond when things go wrong?
And perhaps most importantly, what would it actually feel like to work there?
Two jobs might look almost identical on paper.
But the day-to-day experience can be worlds apart.
Of course, you won't discover everything during an interview.
People are generally on their best behaviour when they're trying to recruit someone.
But thoughtful questions, careful listening and conversations with people who know the organisation can help you identify what matters.
And if you're already in a role where you're struggling, consider whether the problem is the work itself or the environment in which you're being asked to do it.
Sometimes we assume we're losing motivation, becoming less capable or simply not suited to a particular position.
But sometimes we're capable people operating in conditions that make it unnecessarily difficult to succeed.
That doesn't mean we should blame our managers for every challenge.
We still have responsibilities, choices and opportunities to grow.
But it does mean we should recognise that the right environment matters.
Three Questions Worth Asking
Whether you're leading a team or considering your next career move, I'd encourage you to reflect on three questions.
1. What conditions help me do my best work?
Think about trust, autonomy, relationships, clarity, accountability and the freedom to contribute.
2. What behaviours from leaders bring out the best — or worst — in me?
Recognising those patterns can help you make better decisions about the opportunities you pursue.
3. If I lead others, what kind of environment am I creating for them?
Am I someone who encourages people to contribute, challenge ideas and grow?
Or could my behaviour be making their work unnecessarily difficult?
One Final Thought
Looking back, I'm grateful for the leaders like Bonita who helped bring out the best in me.
I'm also grateful, in a different way, for what I learned from working with leaders whose approaches I didn't want to emulate.
Both experiences shaped how I think about leadership.
But one lesson stands out above the others.
People don't thrive simply because they're capable. They thrive when their capabilities meet an environment that allows them to flourish.
And if you're responsible for leading people, you have a significant role in creating that environment.
Because the difference between someone surviving and someone thriving might not be the job they're doing.
It might be the person they're doing it for.